Conflict of Interest Policy
1. Purpose and scope
This policy states how PT Nusaxis Pustaka Cendekia Raya identifies, discloses, and manages conflicts of interest in the publication of its journals. It applies to authors, reviewers, handling editors, editorial board members, guest editors, and publishing staff.
A conflict of interest is any circumstance in which a secondary interest — financial, personal, institutional, or professional — could reasonably be seen to influence, or to appear to influence, editorial judgement. A conflict is not misconduct in itself. The obligation is to disclose it so that it can be managed transparently; what is not permitted is an undisclosed conflict.
This policy is aligned with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices, and with the disclosure expectations of Crossref and of the indexing bodies to which our journals apply.
2. Definitions
- Author services — paid services provided by our corporate affiliate at nusaxis.com, including thesis and dissertation mentoring, statistical analysis, manuscript clinics, editing, and typesetting.
- Editorial decision — any decision to send a manuscript for review, to select reviewers, to accept, to request revision, or to reject.
- Handling editor — the editor assigned to a specific manuscript.
- Immediate family — spouse or partner, children, parents, and siblings.
3. The publisher’s commercial interest: editorial firewall
Our publisher also offers paid author services through nusaxis.com. We state this openly because it is a structural conflict of interest that readers, authors, and indexers are entitled to know about. It is managed by the following rules, which are mandatory and not discretionary:
- No editorial consideration for service clients. Being a client, or having been a client, of any author service creates no right to expedited handling, to a particular reviewer, to a waiver or discount of any fee, or to any favourable editorial outcome. Service clients and non-clients are evaluated by the same criteria and the same process.
- Editors are not told. Staff of the author-services business unit must not disclose to any editor, reviewer, or editorial board member whether a submitting author is, or has been, a client. Manuscripts are handled on the content alone.
- Editorial autonomy. No person employed by, or contracted to, the author-services business unit may hold an editorial decision-making role in any journal of the publisher, and no commercial target, revenue figure, or client relationship may be used as an argument in an editorial decision.
- Acceptance cannot be sold. No fee paid to the publisher or to its affiliates guarantees or purchases acceptance. Acceptance follows peer review and editorial judgement alone.
- Service staff do not touch submissions. Author-services staff have no access to the journal submission system, to reviewer identities, or to manuscripts under evaluation, other than as an author submitting their own work through the ordinary public channel.
- Separate records. Client lists and service invoices are not stored in, linked to, or cross-referenced with the journal’s editorial records.
Any breach of this section is treated as a serious editorial matter under Section 10.
4. Disclosure by authors
At submission, all authors must declare, for each author:
- any financial interest in the subject matter, including employment, consultancy, patents, stock or shareholdings, and honoraria;
- any funding source for the research, with grant numbers where applicable;
- any paid or unpaid relationship with an organisation that stands to gain or lose from the publication;
- whether the author is, or has been, a client of the publisher’s author services, or an employee, editor, reviewer, or editorial board member of this publisher; and
- any personal relationship that could bear on the work, including with a handling editor.
Disclosures are published in the article under a Competing interests heading. Where there is nothing to declare, the article states that the authors have no competing interests to declare. Disclosure does not by itself disqualify a manuscript.
5. Reviewers
Invited reviewers must decline, or declare and be managed, where they:
- have co-authored with any author within the previous three years, or are currently collaborating;
- are employed by, or hold a position at, the same institution as any author (or were within the previous three years);
- have a direct financial interest in the outcome, including competing patents or commercial interests;
- have a personal or professional relationship with any author, positive or adversarial, that could affect their judgement; or
- have reviewed the manuscript in a previous round for a different journal such that anonymity cannot be preserved.
Reviewers must not use knowledge of a manuscript for their own advantage, must not delegate review to another person, and must declare any use of generative AI tools in preparing their report, as required by our AI policy.
6. Editors and editorial board
- Editors must declare any relationship with an author, and must recuse themselves from the manuscript entirely — including from selecting reviewers — where a relationship exists.
- Editors must not handle their own submissions, or those of immediate family, close colleagues, current students or supervisors, or co-authors from the previous three years.
- Editors must declare any financial interest in a manuscript’s subject matter, and any editorial role at a competing journal.
- Editorial board members’ competing interests are published on the journal’s editorial team page and reviewed annually.
- Where a manuscript by an editor or board member is submitted, the journal must appoint an independent editor from outside that journal’s board, and the review must be documented in the manuscript record.
7. How a declared conflict is managed
- The declaration is recorded in the manuscript or reviewer record by the journal manager.
- The editor-in-chief determines the management measure: recusal and reassignment, exclusion from a decision, additional independent review, or no action where the conflict is immaterial.
- Where the conflict concerns the editor-in-chief, the decision passes to the publisher’s [[COI_OFFICER]], who must appoint an external independent editor.
- Disclosures are published in the article. Management measures are recorded but not published where doing so would identify a reviewer.
8. Funding, article processing charges, and sponsorship
All funding sources must be disclosed at submission and published with the article. Where article processing charges apply, the charge is published on the journal’s author guidelines page, is levied after acceptance, and has no bearing on the editorial decision. Waivers and discounts are granted on published, non-discretionary criteria and are recorded. Advertisers and sponsors have no influence over editorial content, and sponsored content is labelled as such.
9. Confidentiality of declarations
A declaration is handled as confidential editorial information until the point of publication, at which time the published Competing interests statement becomes public. Reviewer declarations are never published in a form that would identify the reviewer.
10. Undisclosed or breached conflicts
Where a conflict of interest is discovered after publication, the editor-in-chief will assess it and, where the undisclosed interest could reasonably have affected the outcome, will follow COPE guidance. Depending on severity, the response may include a correction, an expression of concern, a retraction, or a notice of the undisclosed interest attached to the article. Where the breach involves an editor, the publisher will review that person’s editorial role. Repeated breaches by an author, reviewer, or editor may result in suspension from future involvement with our journals.
11. Records and review
Disclosure records and management decisions are retained with the manuscript record for the period required by our records-retention policy. This policy is reviewed annually by the [[COI_OFFICER]] and whenever COPE guidance or our indexing obligations change. The current version and its effective date are always shown at the top of this page.
12. Questions and disclosures
Questions about this policy, or a disclosure that cannot be made through the submission system, should be sent to nodali@nusaxis.com. Reports may be made confidentially, and a person reporting a concern in good faith will not be penalised.